Fairgrounds expansion would cost county $5M
It would cost about $5 million for the county to buy Firemen’s Park from the Cedarburg Fire Department and tear down the dilapidated concrete grandstand, according to a memo that was to be distributed to Ozaukee County supervisors Wednesday morning.
Supervisors were to tour the 16-acre Firemen’s Park Wednesday and then meet at the adjoining Ozaukee County Fairgrounds to discuss making an offer to purchase the park.
The tour and the meeting are open to the public.
From there the board’s Executive Committee, made up of the chairmen of its five standing committees and County Board Chairman Lee Schlenvogt, will develop an offer to make to the Cedarburg Firemen’s Association, County Administrator Jason Dzwinel said.
“The Executive Committee will take some direction from that discussion.,” Dzwinel said Tuesday in an email. “Following that meeting, the Executive Committee will meet and establish a price for an offer and authorize the county administrator and County Board leadership to negotiate within the parameters established.
“If the county and the Cedarburg Firemen’s Association can agree to an offer and terms, which I believe is likely, a resolution authorizing the purchase will be presented to the County Board for approval, perhaps as early as the Dec. 2 County Board meeting.”
Firemen’s Park is home to the four Maxwell Street Days flea markets that have helped fund fire department equipment purchases and operations for decades.
The fire department also stores boats, recreation vehicles, cars and trucks on the site.
The county and fire-department-owned parcels north of downtown Cedarburg are combined each August to form a 39-acre venue for the five-day free county fair.
The nonprofit Ozaukee Agricultural Society operates the Ozaukee County Fair.
The two parcels were roughly the same size until the county bought a 4.4-acre portion for $65,000 per acre in 2009 from the fire department, leaving the current Firemen’s Park at 16.18 acres.
Firemen’s Park features a dirt track, which hosts the fair’s demolition derby and tractor pulls, the fair’s midway and parking. Its most prominent feature is the nearly century-old landmark concrete grandstand, which has not been used to seat people for many years and only serves to shelter vendors and for storage.
Renovating or removing the grandstand would be a major topic in the negotiations and for the future of the county fair.
In his memo, Dzwinel said the fire department approached the county about the potential sale and is asking $2 million for the park.
“It is the smallest amount for which they can sell the property and still fulfill their mission as a volunteer fire department,” he wrote in the memo.
The fire department “believes the property ... would be far more valuable on the open market to a developer or real estate investor, but it is their preference to serve the county and the greater community by preserving our very special county fair at its traditional and long-time location,” he added.
If the 2009 acquisition cost of $65,000 per acre, appreciated at a rate of 1.03% annually, the per acre cost would come to $82,185 today, Dzwinel said.
Using that measure, the total acquisition cost of Firemen’s Park would equal about $1.33 million.
A 2025 appraisal set a baseline for the property at almost $1.5 million with a potential purchase price of between $1.7 million and $2 million.
While that appraisal serves “as the principal valuation reference,” Dzwinel said, “assessing the parcel’s value to the county for continued public fairgrounds use is challenging because comparable sales are limited and market value does not fully capture its educational, recreational and community benefits.”
Demolishing the grandstand and other structures at Firemen’s Park would cost about $3 million, Dzwinel estimated in his memo.
Redeveloping the site would require additional investment, he said.
A 2002 market study commissioned by the City of Cedarburg, the county and fire department listed the county’s acquisition of Firemen’s Park as an option for the future of the fair. Other options were to abandon the grounds and move the fair, at a net cost of about $17 million, or to continue the current arrangement with improvements to the site.
Since that study, the county has improved its portion of the site, including sewer and water improvements, animal wash facilities, electrical upgrades, hand-washing stations, grading, parking, lighting and storm-water management.
The county also built a multi-purpose curling facility, a pole barn and multipurpose building, a drainage-retention pond, the Ozaukee Pavilion, Ascension Columbia St. Mary’s Expo Center, gazebo and additional exhibition buildings.
Dzwiel told the County Board earlier this month that “the county’s interest in potentially purchasing the 16-plus acre property from Cedarburg Firemen’s Inc. is ensuring that this area remains available to continue the activities of the County Fair.”
The 2002 study assumed that under a county purchase the fire department would continue to hold Maxwell Street Days and that other events, such as those held by 4-H, also would continue.
The study cites a 1990 agreement governing the potential sale of Firemen’s Park, which states the fire department must first offer it to the county. If the county declines to buy the property, it must be offered to the City of Cedarburg.
The agreement also contains language that governs how the selling price between the parties will be determined.
Under the agreement, the fire department must inform the county within 60 days of receiving an offer to purchase. It is unclear whether the fire department has a separate outside offer for the property.
Under the 1990 agreement, the price of the property will be determined by an appraiser jointly agreed upon by the county, the fire department and the city.
If they disagree on who will be the appraiser, each entity will hire its own appraiser and the price will be set if two of the three appraisers agree.
The Ozaukee County Fair advertises itself as the last free county fair in Wisconsin. But it still has a big economic impact.
In his memo, Dzwinel cites a 2024 study by Johnson Consulting estimating that the fair:
• Generated $16.1 million in total economic activity.
• Supported approximately $5.5 million in wages, created 120 ongoing jobs.
• Drew 68,900 visitors.
• Generated direct spending of $7.3 million at the fair and surrounding businesses.
• Drew 8,100 visitors from more than 50 miles away, with approximately 300 hotel room nights generated.
• Generated tax revenues totaling $402,700, including $363,900 in state sales taxes, $36,400 in county sales taxes and $2,400 in municipal hotel taxes.
• The fair’s estimated total economic impact was approximately 46% above the benchmark for Upper Midwest fairs with attendance between 25,000 and 100,000.
Category:
Feedback:
Click Here to Send a Letter to the EditorOzaukee Press
Wisconsin’s largest paid circulation community weekly newspaper. Serving Port Washington, Saukville, Grafton, Fredonia, Belgium, as well as Ozaukee County government. Locally owned and printed in Port Washington, Wisconsin.
125 E. Main St.
Port Washington, WI 53074
(262) 284-3494
