Judge upholds TIF district referendum law

Business group had challenged measure forced by residents opposed to data center, TIF for $15B campus

OPPOSITION to the Vantage Data Centers Lighthouse Campus, seen in this photo taken last month, and tax incremental financing to support it resulted in residents circulating a petition and forcing a law regulating future TIF districts in Port Washington. Press file photo
By 
KRISTYN HALBIG ZIEHM
Ozaukee Press staff

Ozaukee County Circuit Judge Adam Gerol on Monday upheld a Port Washington law requiring a binding referendum be held before any tax incremental financing district of more than $10 million be approved — a measure championed by Great Lakes Neighbors United, which has opposed the Vantage Data Centers Lighthouse Campus and the TIF funding associated with it.

Gerol dismissed the lawsuit brought by the Metropolitan Milwaukee Association of Commerce and other business organizations, although he acknowledged the law is likely to be challenged in the future.

“This is likely just the first step on the road this case will travel,” Gerol said.

In a statement, a spokesman for MMAC said the organization remains “deeply concerned about the impact this ordinance will have on Port Washington’s ability to compete for future investment.”

Requiring a referendum before a TIF district can be approved adds “another layer of uncertainty to that process (that) sends the wrong signal to businesses and developers choosing where to invest. Quite simply, those opportunities will go elsewhere.

“We’re disappointed with the judge’s interpretation of the law on multiple fronts and feel confident further examination in higher courts is warranted.”

But Christine Le Jeune, a spokesperson for Great Lakes Neighbors United, which circulated a petition to force a city vote to get the law on the books, said the decision is “a win for every voter in Port Washington and elsewhere in the state.

“Residents asked for a say before large amounts of public money are committed. They gathered signatures. They voted. Today, the court respected that.

“While we welcome this decision, it is unfortunate that citizens had to raise thousands of dollars to go to court and ensure that their voting rights were respected.”

MMAC and the other plaintiffs argued that the Legislature delegated the process of approving TIF districts to municipalities and Joint Review Boards, not voters, adding that the ordinance approved by voters is vague and misleading and will cause irreparable harm to the city and its taxpayers.

But Gerol disagreed, saying that MMAC did not prove any damage from the ordinance.

“It’s all hypothetical,” he said. “None of the plaintiffs provided evidence how, why or when this might happen.

“In essence, all we have are people who say they don’t like the law.”

Gerol also argued that the law does not need to be “drafted with mathematical certainty.”

“To me, it’s quite clear the intent of the ordinance is to require a referendum,” he said. “This is not very well written ...  but it’s not unintelligible. 

“A $10 million component is the key.”

The law, Gerol added, does not conflict with existing laws regulating the process of approving a TIF district but complements them.

“It adds to the other provisions ... but does not conflict with them,” he said.

In another data center-related case, Gerol last week heard testimony in an open records lawsuit brought by Town of Port Washington resident Lynde Uihlein, who  in last August sought a number of records from the City of Port regarding the data center project but did not receive a response until her attorneys sent a follow up letter in October and filed suit in November.

City Clerk Susan Westerbeke acknowledged the delay in responding to the request, saying, “It was a delay but not an intentional delay.”

The number of open records requests received by the city increased significantly last year, she said, from six to 12 requests annually to between 40 and 50 in 2025. And, she said, the requests were more expansive. 

“Our intent is to respond as soon as we are able to,” she said.

The city did not devote additional resources to answering these requests until the end of the year, when the law firm von Briesen and Roper helped with the task, Westerbeke said, and the city did not have a tracking system in place to ensure it handled these requests.

Uihlein’s request “got lost in the shuffle,” City Administrator Melissa Gossett testified.

Attorney Nicholas Cerwin of von Briesen and Roper testified that he began working on open records requests late in the year and started to respond to Uihlein’s request in December, reviewing about 5,400 documents in the process.

But Uihlein’s attorney Christa Westerberg said when the case was filed,  “The Open Records Law is clear: When an authority receives a request, it must comply or deny the request as soon as practicable and without delay. 

“With a project of the size and scope of the data center, the city must prioritize responding to open records requests about the data center as much or more than advancing the data center project.”

Gerol scheduled a Nov. 23 hearing for closing arguments and potentially a decision in the case.

Feedback:

Click Here to Send a Letter to the Editor

Ozaukee Press

Wisconsin’s largest paid circulation community weekly newspaper. Serving Port Washington, Saukville, Grafton, Fredonia, Belgium, as well as Ozaukee County government. Locally owned and printed in Port Washington, Wisconsin.

125 E. Main St.
Port Washington, WI 53074
(262) 284-3494
 

CONNECT


User login