Sierra Club settles lawsuit over Port data center

Group that wanted environmental impact statement accepts broad analysis of facilities paid for by Vantage
By 
KRISTYN HALBIG ZIEHM
Ozaukee Press staff

A strategic analysis of the impact of artificial intelligence data centers in Wisconsin will be performed by the Department of Natural Resources by Jan. 31, 2028, and paid for by Vantage Data Centers to settle a lawsuit filed by the Sierra Club over Vantage’s Lighthouse Campus in Port Washington.

The agreement between the Sierra Club, Vantage and DNR was filed in Ozaukee County Circuit Court Friday, settling a lawsuit brought by the Sierra Club challenging the DNR’s decision not to require an environmental impact statement for Vantage’s Port campus.

“What started as a lawsuit over the environmental review of one data center has become an opportunity to address the data center issue on a much bigger scale,” attorney Michael Greif of Midwest Environmental Advocates, which represented the Sierra Club, said.

“Looking at these impacts holistically is important because the impacts of data centers are statewide. State regulators will now have to examine the cumulative impacts of data center development across Wisconsin.”

The analysis to be done by the DNR will include the impact on aesthetics and light, agriculture, air quality, climate, energy use, greenhouse gas emissions, land use, noise, temperature, water quality, wetlands, wildlife and energy bills.

In creating the study, the DNR will have to hold a public comment period, at least one public hearing on the analysis and maintain a website with information pertaining to the analysis.

“Public input is essential to making informed decisions about how, where and under what conditions data centers should be developed in Wisconsin,” Greif said.

Vantage will pay for the study but shall not control the process of developing the analysis, the stipulation states.

The stipulation notes that the DNR will not be precluded from conducting an environmental impact statement, environmental analysis or other assessment for future projects.

It also noted that the DNR permits for the Lighthouse Data Center Campus remain valid and no additional environmental reviews will be required for the Port center.

Elizabeth Ward, director of the Sierra Club’s Wisconsin Chapter, said, “Port Washington residents deserved a full understanding of the Vantage data center’s potential impacts before permits were issued.

“A statewide analysis will help build a clearer picture of the environmental costs of data center development across Wisconsin. That broader understanding is critical, but it does not replace thorough environmental review of individual projects.

“We expect the DNR to conduct full environmental impact statements for specific proposals when warranted so communities have the information they need before decisions are made.”

Ward added, “AI data centers are massive, thirsty energy hogs and have popped up all over Wisconsin. They could completely change our landscape and use unprecedented amounts of water and energy. Wisconsinites and our regulators need to understand the impacts and opportunities to reduce harm before allowing data centers to move forward.”

Feedback:

Click Here to Send a Letter to the Editor

Ozaukee Press

Wisconsin’s largest paid circulation community weekly newspaper. Serving Port Washington, Saukville, Grafton, Fredonia, Belgium, as well as Ozaukee County government. Locally owned and printed in Port Washington, Wisconsin.

125 E. Main St.
Port Washington, WI 53074
(262) 284-3494
 

CONNECT


User login